Why Willpower Doesn't Work

Introduction

Have you ever set your mind firmly at the start of the day to not drink tonight, only to find yourself almost subconsciously pouring a drink by early evening? If that sounds familiar, you might be relying too heavily on willpower. While the concept of willpower is often held up as the cornerstone of self-control and success, it turns out that it's not the most effective strategy when it comes to quitting alcohol. Many who attempt to take a break from alcohol using willpower alone find themselves feeling miserable, breaking their promises to themselves, and back on the booze before they know it. Depending solely on willpower often sets us up for failure. Fortunately, there are alternative approaches that could help pave the way toward lasting change.

The Myth of Willpower

Willpower is like a muscle that tires out the more we use it throughout the day. Research shows that we only have a limited supply of willpower each day, which diminishes as we make various decisions—big or small. By evening, our "willpower pool" is pretty depleted. A study by Baumeister et al. in 1998 demonstrated that decision fatigue leads to diminished willpower reserves as the day progresses, making it much harder to stick to our well-intended goals by evening.

Benjamin Hardy's insightful book, *Why Willpower Doesn't Work*, delves into this dilemma, highlighting that willpower is often overwhelmed by biological and psychological influences. Stress, lack of sleep, and emotional upheavals drain our resolve even more, leaving us vulnerable to the habitual pull of a drink in our hand by the time evening comes around.

Environment and Triggers

One significant factor contributing to willpower's inefficacy is our environment. We are, like it or not, creatures of habit, and familiar sights, sounds, and events can trigger automatic responses. If your evenings are consistently spent in an environment where drinking is the norm, your willpower doesn't stand much chance against these powerful triggers—unless you're well prepared before evening comes.

Hardy notes that relying on willpower without addressing the triggers and environment that reinforce unwanted habits is akin to swimming upstream. Realizing the profound influence of our surroundings and restructuring them to minimize triggers is essential for sustainable behavioral change.

Beyond Willpower

If we are looking to take a break from alcohol or even continue a break from alcohol, it would make sense to move away from the concept of willpower as the sole strategy. Instead of focusing solely on willpower, consider a holistic, multi-layered approach that involves emotional-led behavior changes, deconstructing beliefs and habits that don’t serve us, and biohacking physiology—together with a positive, supportive community.

This approach helps to turn the negative thought "I’m not going to drink tonight" into a positive one, such as "I want to sleep well tonight so that I wake feeling great and get up early for a yoga class before my busy day begins."

Tactics to help achieve this include:

  • Biohacking Physiology

    Understanding and leveraging your body's natural rhythms and needs can give you an edge. Eating well, ensuring adequate sleep, and engaging in regular physical activity can bolster your resolve by optimizing your physiological state.

  • Emotional-Led Behavior Change

    Rather than suppressing emotions, which can deplete willpower, embrace them and seek to understand the underlying emotional triggers that drive your urge to drink. Practicing emotional awareness is something many of us were never taught, but by naming and becoming aware of an emotion, we can reach powerful breakthroughs. These allow us to make changes based on the emotions we want to feel instead.

  • Deconstructing Limiting Beliefs and Habits

    Most habits are underpinned by beliefs and old narratives that no longer serve us. By identifying and challenging these beliefs, it becomes much easier to pave new paths toward healthier habits and choices.

  • Changing Your Environment

    Once again, take a cue from Hardy. Alter your environment to support your goals. Remove temptations, surround yourself with supportive peers (outside of family or friends if they are not as supportive as you would like), and immerse yourself in activities that don't revolve around alcohol.

Conclusion

While willpower might get you through a trying day or two, it is not a long-term solution if you’re trying to ditch alcohol or maintain a long-term alcohol-free lifestyle with ease. Yes, it can be done, and some people have successfully achieved this, but it’s not the easiest path. Honestly, if there’s a simpler way, why not opt for that?

The key to success lies in understanding deeper motivations, optimizing your environment, and offering yourself a lot of self-compassion during the journey. If you're ready to make a meaningful shift away from alcohol, consider an approach that integrates physiology, emotion, and habit transformation. By doing so, you're not just quitting alcohol; you're crafting a lifestyle where you thrive without it.

If you're interested in learning more about effective strategies to take a break from alcohol or to help you maintain and live a healthier, fulfilling alcohol-free lifestyle, book a call with us to learn more HERE.

 
Next
Next

Switching Off: The Truth About Alcohol and Relaxation